Israeli court orders extradition to US of Brooklyn man in 2008 assault in Crown Heights


By Associated Press

JERUSALEM — An Israeli court has ordered a Brooklyn man extradited to the U.S. in connection with an April 2008 assault on a black man.

Yitzchak Shuchat is suspected of beating Andrew Charles in the Crown Heights section of Brooklyn. The area is known for 1991 race riots between Orthodox Jews and blacks.

Thursday’s extradition order cites a U.S. request over the 2008 attack, alleging an unidentified man on a bicycle sprayed Charles with mace while Shuchat stepped out of an SUV, struck Charles with a wooden club and drove off.

Shuchat fled to Canada, then to Israel in May 2008. He was indicted in the U.S. on hate crime and other charges.

Police suspected the attack followed reports that black youths had pelted neighborhood homes with rocks.

Shuchat belonged to a Jewish street patrol group, the Shmira.



16 Responses to “Israeli court orders extradition to US of Brooklyn man in 2008 assault in Crown Heights”

  1. In Your Own Words Says:

  2. who cares Says:



  3. CHER Says:

    Whose perp #1 in the sketch above?

  4. Jury #6 Says:

    Now it’s up to the jury to decide if Shuchat is guilty or not.

    Justice will prevail!!!

  5. Take The Deal Says:

    Yitzchok should take a deal and run.

    I will gather tonight with my friends at the CHJCC and we will come up with a good deal for Yitzchok. A deal he wont and can not refuse.

  6. shalom Says:

    there is a group of individuals in this community who make noisy “anti mesira” campaigns (@ elections etc). yet it seems that they are (also) serial mosrim – and proud of it.

    Just my observation…

    • WhoIsShmira? Says:

      Who are they (this group) and what Mesira have they done and to whom did they do this mesira to?

      Please write more details and send any and all evidence that you have to back any claims you have.

      For rumors, hearsay, “observations” and propaganda go visit:

      Here at WIS we deal with hard facts, truth, evidence etc…

      Awaiting a response.

  7. Mind Boggling Says:

    It is really mind boggling how much hatred this this guy has in his heart that during his sister’s wedding he could not resist committing mesira against his fellow Yid! Well it looks like he is about to get his comeuppance very soon!

  8. Jay Says:

    Hopefully, he’ll serve some jail time in the state prison with a large population of black inmates. Maybe he’ll have some tolerance beat into him.

    Two year ago this exact time period, the shmira guys thought the above would be the best thing for six other Crown Heighters.

  9. shmiramesiraexposed Says:

    The only one Yitzchok Shuchat can blame for his troubles is Yitzchok Shuchat.

    Shuchat is a Mosser, he should be punished!!!

  10. person Says:

    To Shalom:

    Obviously you never opened up a Choshen Mishpat and therefore you have no clue what is a Messira and what isn’t.

    While its very clear from Shas and Rambam and Shulchan Aruch that Messira is from the very worst things a person can do, the same Rambam and Shulchan Aruch also tell you that there are instances that it is allowed! Such as if the person mossering on you is ruining your life and causing you 6 digit monetary losses by relentlessly calling 311, this not being enough a few calls were made to child services etc. On such a person there is no “Geder” of messirah!

    You may argue “how do you know he did it?” well there are tapes/recordings which some of them were displayed here on this very web-site! So there is no doubt about it as to the fact that Yitzchok Shuchat is a vicious Mosser! efforts were even made to reach out to him and explain to him what he was doing and where this was going to end up (this too is a fact and recorded), but he would not hear and insisted on his messira barrage! too such an extant that he even placed a 311 call from his sisters wedding! how low can a man stoop?!

    The following are the laws of Messira as they are written in the Alter Rebbes Shulchan Aruch:

    Shulchan Aruch
    Code Of The Jewish Law
    By Rabbi Shneur Zalman Of Liadi
    Laws of Money Damages – (Laws of Messira)
    [Chosen Mishpot – Kehot Printing –Safer Vov- Page Kof-Chof]

    For Original Hebrew Print – Click Here

    [Free Translation]

    (6) It is forbidden to Masser a Jew in to the hands of a Goy (Gentile), it makes no difference if its his body (גוף) or money (ממון), even ממון קל, which means even if it’s a “light” (small) amount of money.,

    This prohibition (אסור) applies by דיבור, which means outright Messira through speech, Or even revealing what a fellow Jew wants to do, for example giving a hint, for example: if the Goy (גוי) asks the Yid where he can find strew, it is forbidden to tell him that it can be found in a specific Yid’s house, or even to just point to the Yid’s house, – without even saying anything, and anyone that does Massira has no part in the world to come.

    Even a wicked person (רשע) and a sinner (בעל עבירות), it is forbidden to Massir on him, both in regard to his body (גוף) or money (ממונו), and even if this person is a constant bother, for example, he’s always harassing you, it’s forbidden to Masser.

    However, if this wicked person Massered on you, you are allowed to Masser on him, if there is reason to believe that this wicked person will continue his Mossering and the only way you can save yourself is by- Mossering on the wicked person or in a case that you were Massered on and that Messira was not dismissed, meaning it’s ongoing, your allowed to Masser, if that’s your last resort, and no other way out.

    Also one that is violent who regularly hits people and there is no other way to protect yourself from him, unless you will Masser him to Goyim, that they shall take his money or “cut off his hands” that he may not be violent again. However, someone who hit his friend but he is not regularly violent rather this was a one time thing, it is forbidden even for the person that was hit, to Masser his friend, for even though if in this case, the person that was hit does Masser, there are those opinions which exempt him from (דיני אדם) Judgment from man, because a person isn’t (”נתפס על צערו”) [Baba Bathra 16: Raba said: This teaches that a man is not held responsible for what he says when in distress[. Still (לכתחילה) to begin with it is forbidden to according to everyone and he is a Mosser (if he does).

    And even if you have a violent Jew, and he doesn’t want to go to Bais Din, it is forbidden to go to the authorities to force him to come to a Din Torah, until you receive permission from Bais Din, also to force him through the means of Goyim to fulfill the Psak (Halachik Ruling) of Bais din, it is forbidden till you have consent from Bais Din.

    (7) Someone that Masser’s it is permitted to kill him, in any place, and at any time, even in today’s time, even before he actually Masser’s, like if he says “I’m going to Masser on someone either on his actual body or money etc…” he has permitted himself to death, and we warn him, and we tell him: Do not Masser. If he has Chutzpa and says no, I’m going to Masser anyways, it is a Mitzva (commandment) to kill him, and whoever is first in doing so, the merit is his.

    For someone that goes to Masser money of a Jew into the hands of Goyim, it’s as if he’s “chasing” (”רודף”) after his soul. And if someone is “chasing” (”רודף”) after your friend to kill him, it is allowed to save him (your friend), by killing the killer (Mosser).

    And if there is no opportunity to warn him (the Mosser), you do not need to warn him. However if you can save the victim by hurting the killer (Mosser), for example by cutting off his tongue, or to poke out his eyes, then it’s forbidden to kill him (the Mosser).

    (8) If the Mosser followed thought with his plot (of Messira), it is forbidden to kill him, unless he’s “assumed in Messira”, which means he has done Messira three times, then you can kill for he may continue to Mosser on others. It is forbidden to destroy the money of a Mosser by hand, meaning by physical action, or through Messira to Goyim, even though it’s permitted to destroy his body (by killing him). For his money is fit for his inheritors. However it’s permitted to cause him lose of money, because since his body is void (הפקר) so is his money, and for sure you don’t have to pick up his lost item to return to him. However it is forbidden to take the Mosser’s money for yourself (even if it’s something that the Mosser lost) since it is fit for his inheritors.

    There are those who say that a Mosser has the law of a Mumar (מומר) to the whole Torah (see Rambam Laws of Repentance, Chapter 3, law 9, for what a Mumar for the whole Torah is). And if you find the Mosser’s lost object it is yours and is forbidden to return it to him….

    (9) Someone that’s assumed as a Mosser, and it seems that the only reason why his words are heard is because of his money, meaning he is rich, and if he would be poor his words will not be heard, it is permitted to destroy (לאבד) his money, or to Masser on him to Goyim, for with this you are saving other people from this Mosser’s Messira.

  11. antimesira Says:

    To all you self righteous people who all of a sudden woke up about Mesira. Ye, you guys, the ones who justified and excused Mesira all these years, I’m talking to you.

    No worries mates. Just like the Shomrim Six were vindicated so to will Shuchat be vindicated.

    After all, being tried by a jury of 12 is what you wanted for the Shomrim Six, whats the problem now.

    And also, if hes guilty, he deserves to go to jail, isn’t that the attitude you had two years ago?

    To ‘person’:

    I know you mean well and all that you said is 100% true, BUT the time for convincing is over, these people can’t be convinced, they must be defeated!!!

  12. KNOCKED OVER!!!! Says:

  13. Mossrim wake up!!! Says:

    I like how the Mossrim (the crying Mossrim) have all of a sudden discovered concepts like…

    Ahavas Israel

    Rachmones – Mercy


    Sinas Chinum – Baseless hate

    and the most laughable one of them all…

    Mesira is wrong!!!

    Cry babies cry, you ain’t seen nothing yet!!!

    • antimesira Says:

      Theres another word their trying to get out there to justify and excuse the Messira Shuchat did by calling 311 and that words is…


      They are not writing this word in English, which would be REVENGE, because in English it sounds so wrong, but somehow in Hebrew they thing it will slid.

      As usual they make vague statements, without any details or/and facts to back them up.

      At this point, whatever they have to say can and will be said in a court of law.

      In court we will get…

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: