EXCLUSIVE: Possible Lawsuit Against Rebbi Rosenberg

by

In the last week WIS has received numerous emails calling our attention to possible legal action against the Zabla Bais Din. All this as Rabbi Rosenberg has to come to a final decision over Braun candidacy, and Braun promoters want to bring Braun in for Yud Tes Kislav to CROWN him Rov, regardless if he has Smicha or not. The emails allude to the fact that the Zabla Beth Din, primarily Rabbi Avraham Rosenberg, have violated his own verdict – Psak Din.

“What was the point of the Psak if  in the end nothing in it really matters?” asked one resident. He continued “Your trying to rebuild a Bais Din that the community should take seriously, while the whole Psak on which its based is one big joke” is this the way things are done “My 13 year old son has the same eligibility” he added. “He’s under 40, No Smicha, and even knows how to use a Blackbarry” he concluded.

So can there really be legal action?

The arguments being made is that after so much time and money was wasted on a Din Torah, the community was let down.

The Zabla Beth Din came out with a ruling which is legally binding,  yet we find that Rabbi Rosenberg has broken the rules more then once. Note: every-time a rule was broken it was done so for the benefit of the Mossrim and trouble rousers.

Some of the rules that were broken:

There was a time limit for each side to present their candidate. Braun came late, Rabbi Rosenberg let him run nevertheless.

There was an age limit, 40 and up. Braun is not 40 and nevertheless Rabbi Rosenberg let him run.

The candidates had to have Smicha, and Rabbi Rosernberg signed off on Braun without checking his documentation. And once the election passed it was confirmed that Braun did not in fact have Smicha when he ran.

So can there really be a lawsuit from either party over the full payment of the Zabla?

What WIS finds disturbing is that the Din Torah was meant to bring peace and harmony to Crown Heights and the Beth Din, yet we are back to square one.

Interesting that Zaki Tamir does not want to take responsibility, being a lawyer, and  knowing full well what it entails.

b. Challenges and Qualifications
i. Is the vaad responsible to review any qualifications associated with the Rav? If yes, to what degree, specifically? And if not, who is? And need we, the vaad, be concerned with such matters at all?

Read Zaki Letter Here: Letter of Vaad Hakohol Chairman Zaki Tamir to Beis Din of Zabl”a

Related: Follow the evidence and judge for yourself

About these ads

8 Responses to “EXCLUSIVE: Possible Lawsuit Against Rebbi Rosenberg”

  1. me Says:

    I read Zakis letter last night but did not realize how couscous he was being until you pointed it out. I just read it again and now it makes sense.

    Zaki is covering his own Tuches. Good for him.

  2. FAILED PSAK Says:

    So it turns out that the biggest violator of the Psak was the authors-Beth Din- that complied it.

    This does not look good.

    What place will this Psak have in history? ZERO.

    The Psak has already turned in to a game, all thanks of course to Rabbi Rosenberg and his Mishichist Mossrim friends.

  3. M.L. Says:

    So after everything- the time and money spent- we end up back in court, what a bloody shame.

  4. Joeshmo Says:

    so whos the mossrim again

  5. Anon Says:

    EXCLUSIVE: Din Torah followed by a Lawsuit.
    The community with Zaki Tamir -as head of the council and lawyer- Against Rabbi Rosenberg .
    Subject: 1) returning all the monies Rosenberg received, back to the community”.
    2) penalty for embarrassment of the entire community.

    Based on the fact that the Zabla Beis Din was hired specifically to bring peace and harmony in the Badatz of Crown Heights and to the entire community, yet Rosenberg made the fights much bigger, the split in the Beth Din and community much harder, and instead of harmony- chaos prevails in the entire neighborhood of Crown Heights….
    In addion he violated his own verdict – Psak Din.
    Rosenberge has broken the rules more then once. (Note: every-time a rule was broken it was done so for the benefit of the Shweys trouble rousers ) .

    Some of the rules that were broken:

    There was a time limit for each side to present their candidate. Braun came late, Rabbi Rosenberg let him run nevertheless.
    There was an age limit, 40 and up. Braun is not 40 and nevertheless Rabbi Rosenberg let him run.
    The candidates had to have Smicha, and Rabbi Rosernberg signed off on Braun without checking his documentation. And once the election passed it was confirmed that Braun did not in fact have Smicha when he ran.

    Based on the above facts etc… a Din Torah followed by a lawsuit is being prepared against Rabbi Rosenberg and his BD…. the main arguments 1) returning all the Moneis Rosenberg received 2) damage made to the community, and to Rabbis Osdoba Shwey Segal. etc..for not not receiving their salary due to to Rosenberg’s payments. 3) embarrassing the entire Crown heights community, by permitting to elect a young spring with no Semichah and no experience what so never as a Rabbi.

    Concerned residents
    of our community

  6. chaim Says:

    listen to this short story the Rebbe relates about how a loosing party to a Din Torah usually reacts…

    http://www.zshare.net/audio/860416753d482199

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s


Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 36 other followers

%d bloggers like this: